Measured against published problems, misses included.
- 44 of 46
- closed-form worked examples inside the stated tolerance
- 238 of 333
- finite-element benchmark rows within tolerance of an outside reference
- 37
- outside tolerance, each listed with its measured difference and reason
- 17
- published sources cited by the closed-form registry
The public record of how our engines compare with published problems, in two registries: the closed-form engines against printed worked examples (first table), and the finite-element solver against vendor tutorials, papers and analytical solutions (second table). Each row names the source and page, the value the source prints, the value our engine returns for the same inputs, the difference, and the tolerance with the reason for it.
Measured by our engineers on 2026-11-11 against the published value. Every row is public, misses included, so anyone can check it.
The suite runs each closed-form benchmark in your browser and stamps a reproducible SHA-256 hash. The manual groups both registries and every cited validation suite by analysis, deviations first, as a PDF too.
Showing 20 of 46 rows.
| Problem | Ours | Published | Difference | Tolerance | Status | Details | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bearing capacity — closed form | |||||||
EN 1997-1 Annex D Nq at φ′d = 38° (M1) BC-JRC-A33-NQ-M1 | 48.933 | 48.87 | +0.13 % | ± 0.3 % | Ours 48.933Published 48.87+0.13 % | Pass | |
| |||||||
EN 1997-1 Annex D Nγ at φ′d = 38° (M1) BC-JRC-A33-NG-M1 | 74.899 | 74.8 | +0.13 % | ± 0.3 % | Ours 74.899Published 74.8+0.13 % | Pass | |
| |||||||
EN 1997-1 Annex D Nq at φ′d = tan⁻¹(tan 38°/1.25) (M2) BC-JRC-A33-NQ-M2 | 23.195 | 23.17 | +0.11 % | ± 0.3 % | Ours 23.195Published 23.17+0.11 % | Pass | |
| |||||||
EN 1997-1 Annex D Nγ at φ′d (M2) BC-JRC-A33-NG-M2 | 27.745 | 27.72 | +0.09 % | ± 0.3 % | Ours 27.745Published 27.72+0.09 % | Pass | |
| |||||||
Terzaghi, square footing — cohesion + surcharge terms (the Nγ term is a convention comparison, not reproduced) BC-DAS-4.1 | 968.33kPa | 968.2kPa | +0.01 % | ± 0.5 % | Ours 968.33 kPaPublished 968.2 kPa+0.01 % | Pass | |
| |||||||
General bearing equation, same footing BC-DAS-4.3 | 1,374kPa | 1,373.2kPa | +0.06 % | ± 0.5 % | Ours 1,374 kPaPublished 1,373.2 kPa+0.06 % | Pass | |
| |||||||
Inclined load β = 20° BC-DAS-4.5 | 273.8kPa | 273.66kPa | +0.05 % | ± 0.5 % | Ours 273.8 kPaPublished 273.66 kPa+0.05 % | Pass | |
| |||||||
Eccentric strip, e = 0.2 m BC-DAS-4.7 | 3,288.2kPa | 3,287.4kPa | +0.03 % | ± 0.5 % | Ours 3,288.2 kPaPublished 3,287.4 kPa+0.03 % | Pass | |
| |||||||
Eccentric + inclined strip BC-DAS-4.12 | 461.67kPa | 461.98kPa | −0.07 % | ± 0.5 % | Ours 461.67 kPaPublished 461.98 kPa−0.07 % | Pass | |
| |||||||
Case study — Bozozuk silo, φ = 0 BC-DAS-SILO | 182.5kPa | 181.8kPa | +0.39 % | ± 0.5 % | Ours 182.5 kPaPublished 181.8 kPa+0.39 % | Pass | |
| |||||||
Terzaghi, φ 30°, B 1.5 m BC-BOW-4-1 | 1,641.2kPa | 1,638.8kPa | +0.15 % | ± 1 % | Ours 1,641.2 kPaPublished 1,638.8 kPa+0.15 % | Pass | |
| |||||||
Hansen, submerged tank footing BC-BOW-4-2-H | 1,817.8kPa | 1,812kPa | +0.32 % | ± 1 % | Ours 1,817.8 kPaPublished 1,812 kPa+0.32 % | Pass | |
| |||||||
Meyerhof (1963), submerged tank footing BC-BOW-4-2-M | 2,672.7kPa | 2,659kPa | +0.52 % | ± 1 % | Ours 2,672.7 kPaPublished 2,659 kPa+0.52 % | Pass | |
| |||||||
Hansen, two-way eccentric 1.8 m square BC-BOW-4-5 | 5,050.2kPa | 5,088kPa | −0.74 % | ± 1.5 % | Ours 5,050.2 kPaPublished 5,088 kPa−0.74 % | Pass | |
| |||||||
Meyerhof inclined load — total checked against the book-consistent value, NOT the printed 399.9 kPa (documented source error) BC-BOW-4-7-TOTAL | 388kPa | 388.72kPa | −0.19 % | ± 1 % | Ours 388 kPaPublished 388.72 kPa−0.19 % | Pass | |
| |||||||
Meyerhof inclined load — cohesion term c·Nc·dc·ic BC-BOW-4-7-C | 343.29kPa | 344kPa | −0.21 % | ± 0.5 % | Ours 343.29 kPaPublished 344 kPa−0.21 % | Pass | |
| |||||||
Square pad on soft clay, undrained, DA1-C1 BC-DG-6.1-UND-DA1C1 | 586.79kN | 586kN | +0.13 % | ± 1 % | Ours 586.79 kNPublished 586 kN+0.13 % | Pass | |
| |||||||
Square pad on soft clay, undrained, DA1-C2 (c_u,d = 30/1.4) BC-DG-6.1-UND-DA1C2 | 434kN | 433kN | +0.23 % | ± 1 % | Ours 434 kNPublished 433 kN+0.23 % | Pass | |
| |||||||
Square pad on soft clay, undrained, DA2 BC-DG-6.1-UND-DA2 | 580.11kN | 580kN | +0.02 % | ± 1 % | Ours 580.11 kNPublished 580 kN+0.02 % | Pass | |
| |||||||
Square pad on soft clay, undrained, DA3 BC-DG-6.1-UND-DA3 | 600.69kN | 600kN | +0.11 % | ± 1 % | Ours 600.69 kNPublished 600 kN+0.11 % | Pass | |
| |||||||
Δ = (ours − reference) / reference. Runtime is one warm call of the engine on the measuring machine, excluding page and network time. A miss stays in this table until the engine is corrected or the source is shown, with evidence, to be in error.
Finite-element verification registry
The finite-element solver keeps its own registry, alongside the table above. Each row compares a solver result with a value from outside the solver where one exists: a value printed in a published document, a closed-form or analytical solution, or a vendor’s published verification result. Self-checks compare the solver with something derived inside this project (for example our own TypeScript solver, a hand calculation or an input); they are labelled as such and counted separately from comparisons with an outside source. The registry was last updated 2026-11-14.
By what the row is compared against: 224 published / analytical reference; 42 vendor-published value; 53 self-check; 14 no reference value. Deviations and pending rows stay in the table: a deviation is a result outside the stated tolerance (or a difference the row records as known), and pending and blocked rows are problems the solver is still being extended to run. Recorded and superseded rows are kept as well, with the reason, so nothing is removed from the record. What each status means is listed below.
- Pass
- Our value is within the tolerance the row states.
- Deviation
- Our value is outside the stated tolerance, or the row records a known difference; it is not explained away.
- Recorded, no published value
- We ran the case, but the source publishes no number to compare with, so there is no verdict.
- Superseded
- An older stand-in or umbrella row, replaced by the newer row or rows named on it. It is not counted as a pass or as open.
- Pending
- The case can be run with the solver as it is, and has not been run yet.
The notes under each row are our engineers’ working notes. Where a note cites “D” and a number (for example D114) it refers to an entry in our internal defect log; “doc” and a number is an internal design note. Neither is published. Ask us at hello@terrabrains.ai and we will explain the entry behind any row.
Showing 30 of 333 rows.
| Problem | Ours | Published | Difference | Status | Details | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
total footing force 2π·|Force-Y| at 0.05 m indentation (rigid rough footing, case A) plaxis-2d-tut1-a-force · vs vendor value | 600.77kN | —kN | +2.17 % | Ours 600.77 kNPublished — kN+2.17 % | Pass | |
| ||||||
Force-Y per radian at ΣMstage = 0.3943 (u = 0.0197 m) plaxis-2d-tut1-a-fy-0.3943 · vs vendor value | -53.974kN/rad | —kN/rad | +0.34 % | Ours -53.974 kN/radPublished — kN/rad+0.34 % | Pass | |
| ||||||
maximum total displacement (the footing) plaxis-2d-tut1-a-umax | 0.05m | 0.05m | 0.00 % | Ours 0.05 mPublished 0.05 m0.00 % | Pass | |
| ||||||
K0 procedure: σ′v = −Σγh + p, σ′h = 0.5 σ′v, p = 10(2 − y) — worst |error| over every integration point plaxis-2d-tut1-k0-effective-stress · Self-check | 1.00e-12kPa | hand calculation (γ_unsat 17 above y = 2, γ_sat 20 below, γ_w 10, K0 = 1 − sin 30° = 0.5) | 0.00 % | Ours 1.00e-12 kPaPublished hand calculation (γ_unsat 17 above y = 2… kPa0.00 % | Pass | |
| ||||||
|u| of node (0, 4) vs ΣMstage under 188 kPa on the plate footing (EA 5e6, EI 8.5e3, ν 0), axisymmetric; PLAXIS Figure 1–27: 0.5 → 0.0156, 0.6 → 0.0207, 0.8 → 0.0328, 0.9 → 0.0398, 1.0 → 0.0496 m (±0.… plaxis-2d-tut1-b-flexible · vs vendor value | 0.048745m | —m | −1.72 % | Ours 0.048745 mPublished — m−1.72 % | Pass | |
| ||||||
mesh-refinement study of the case-A force 2π·|Force-Y| (full Newton, tol 1e-8, tension cut-off on) plaxis-2d-tut1-a-refinement | several values | — | — | Ours several valuesPublished —— | Deviation | |
| ||||||
collapse average stress p = 2πF/(πR²) of a smooth rigid circular footing plaxis-verif-circular-footing-cox | 227.284kPa | 225.6kPa | +0.75 % | Ours 227.284 kPaPublished 225.6 kPa+0.75 % | Pass | |
| ||||||
settlement at the centre of the tank plaxis-verif-flexible-tank | 74.207mm | 74.44mm | −0.31 % | Ours 74.207 mmPublished 74.44 mm−0.31 % | Pass | |
| ||||||
normalised cavity pressure p/c at (a − a0)/a0 = 4 (also 0.4 / 1.2 / 2.8 within 0.15 %) plaxis-verif-cavity-pressure | 7.6812 | 7.6846 | −0.04 % | Ours 7.6812Published 7.6846−0.04 % | Pass | |
| ||||||
radius of the plastic zone at a = 5 m (outermost plastic integration point) plaxis-verif-cavity-rp | 28.003m | 28.28m | −0.99 % | Ours 28.003 mPublished 28.28 m−0.99 % | Pass | |
| ||||||
normalised cavity pressure p/c at (a − a0)/a0 = 4, updated mesh (worst step over the curve −0.22 %) plaxis-verif-cavity-large-pressure | 5.5628 | 5.5668 | −0.07 % | Ours 5.5628Published 5.5668−0.07 % | Pass | |
| ||||||
radius of the plastic zone at a = 5 m, current configuration (outermost plastic integration point) plaxis-verif-cavity-large-rp | 48.74m | 49.11m | −0.76 % | Ours 48.74 mPublished 49.11 m−0.76 % | Pass | |
| ||||||
ux / uy of the corner nodes plaxis-verif-biaxial-le · Self-check | identical to 1e-13 | identical | 0.00 % | Ours identical to 1e-13Published identical0.00 % | Pass | |
| ||||||
γxy plaxis-verif-biaxial-shear | 0.0025 | 0.0025 | 0.00 % | Ours 0.0025Published 0.00250.00 % | Pass | |
| ||||||
failure σ1 (load control) plaxis-verif-biaxial-mc | -6.4641kPa | -6.4641kPa | 0.00 % | Ours -6.4641 kPaPublished -6.4641 kPa0.00 % | Pass | |
| ||||||
footing force for 0.01 m plaxis-verif-smooth-rigid-strip | 15.225kN/m | 15.148kN/m | +0.51 % | Ours 15.225 kN/mPublished 15.148 kN/m+0.51 % | Pass | |
| ||||||
centre settlement plaxis-verif-boussinesq | 0.09033mm | 0.091mm | −0.73 % | Ours 0.09033 mmPublished 0.091 mm−0.73 % | Pass | |
| ||||||
mean ultimate stress, smooth / rough (PLAXIS 2D 7.831 / 9.168 kPa) plaxis-verif-davis-booker | 7.8335 / 9.1826 | 7.800 / 9.090 | +0.43 / +1.02 % | Ours 7.8335 / 9.1826Published 7.800 / 9.090+0.43 / +1.02 % | Pass | |
| ||||||
settlement under the strip (PLAXIS 2D 0.04845 / 0.04965 m; Gibson 0.05) plaxis-verif-gibson | 0.04951m | 0.05m | −0.98 % | Ours 0.04951 mPublished 0.05 m−0.98 % | Pass | |
| ||||||
settlement under the strip (PLAXIS 2D 0.04845 / 0.04965 m; Gibson 0.05) plaxis-verif-gibson-2011-a | 0.04599m | 0.05m | −8.02 % | Ours 0.04599 mPublished 0.05 m−8.02 % | Deviation | |
| ||||||
total discharge under the dam (impermeable wall, confined flow) plaxis-verif-confined-wall-Q | 0.81959m³/day/m | 0.82m³/day/m | −0.05 % | Ours 0.81959 m³/day/mPublished 0.82 m³/day/m−0.05 % | Pass | |
| ||||||
Dam I: total discharge under the dam plaxis-verif-concrete-dam-I-Q | 1.03e-5m³/s/m | 1.03e-5m³/s/m | +0.15 % | Ours 1.03e-5 m³/s/mPublished 1.03e-5 m³/s/m+0.15 % | Pass | |
| ||||||
Dam II (upstream screen): total discharge plaxis-verif-concrete-dam-II-Q | 8.69e-6m³/s/m | 8.84e-6m³/s/m | −1.74 % | Ours 8.69e-6 m³/s/mPublished 8.84e-6 m³/s/m−1.74 % | Pass | |
| ||||||
Dam III (downstream screen): total discharge plaxis-verif-concrete-dam-III-Q | 8.69e-6m³/s/m | 8.84e-6m³/s/m | −1.74 % | Ours 8.69e-6 m³/s/mPublished 8.84e-6 m³/s/m−1.74 % | Pass | |
| ||||||
Dam I: uplift pressure head at A (dam toe) plaxis-verif-concrete-dam-I-uplift | 2.181m | 2.25m | −3.07 % | Ours 2.181 mPublished 2.25 m−3.07 % | Pass | |
| ||||||
Dam II: uplift pressure head at A plaxis-verif-concrete-dam-II-uplift | 2.073m | 2.13m | −2.68 % | Ours 2.073 mPublished 2.13 m−2.68 % | Pass | |
| ||||||
Dam III: uplift pressure head at A (upstream side of the screen) plaxis-verif-concrete-dam-III-uplift | 4.004m | 3.87m | +3.46 % | Ours 4.004 mPublished 3.87 m+3.46 % | Pass | |
| ||||||
seepage face length along the slope above the tail water plaxis-verif-seepage-length | 25.375m | 25.5m | −0.49 % | Ours 25.375 mPublished 25.5 m−0.49 % | Pass | |
| ||||||
seepage face height on the downstream boundary above the tail water plaxis-verif-muskat | 1.5867m | 1.55m | +2.37 % | Ours 1.5867 mPublished 1.55 m+2.37 % | Pass | |
| ||||||
total discharge through an unconfined sand layer plaxis-verif-sand-layer-Q | 0.15387m³/day/m | 0.15m³/day/m | +2.58 % | Ours 0.15387 m³/day/mPublished 0.15 m³/day/m+2.58 % | Pass | |
| ||||||
Δ = (ours − reference) / reference, in percent, as recorded in the registry; where a row has no reference value it is against the vendor-published value and says so. Each status is the registry’s own. The “Self-check” label follows the registry’s description of the reference.
Bring a job you have already signed.
Run it here and set our number beside yours. 14 days free, no card.